Forging a successful and productive team can only occur when workers can depend on each other to do their jobs. Unfortunately, mistakes and accidents can happen, and workers do get injured. Employee negligence and errors are one of the leading causes of on-the-job injuries.
Reporting Employee Error
Employees are not legally required to report negligent coworkers, although your company’s policy may require it. Also, when a coworker’s behavior puts others at risk, reporting it is ethically the right thing to do. Whether out of lack of proper training, personal problems, or the consumption of alcohol or drugs, coworker errors can result in injuries. If you can do something to prevent injury, you have an obligation to do so.
An employee who is injured on the job has a right to collect workers’ compensation benefits, whether his injury is due to a coworker’s mistake or any other accident. Negligence is not a factor in worker’s comp; the on-the-job injury is all that matters.
Workers’ comp benefits pay for medical and therapy bills, out-of-pocket expenses (medications, bandages, etc.), and approximately two-thirds of a worker’s lost wages. Pain and suffering is generally not covered under workers’ compensation.
Third-party Negligence Claims
Employers’ Legal Duty to Act
Injured workers usually are limited by law to workers’ compensation benefits. Under certain conditions though, a worker may claim additional damages by filing a third-party claim against his employer.
An employer who fails to intervene or remove an incapacitated or error-plagued worker can be held liable if the employee’s negligence results in injuries. A third-party action may entitle an injured worker to payment of medical and therapy bills, out-of-pocket expenses, total lost wages, and an amount for pain and suffering.
The Basis of a Third-party Claim
Employers who become aware of a worker’s job-related errors normally have no legal duty to intervene, discipline, relocate, or terminate that worker. There may be legitimate reasons for not doing so.
The employer’s legal duty to intervene changes if he becomes aware that an employee’s negligence jeopardizes the health and safety of other workers. A third-party action must be based on proof that the employer’s negligence (in not taking corrective measures to eliminate a worker’s errors) rises to a level gross negligence or a wanton disregard for workers’ safety.
Proving a Third-party Claim
There isn’t a strict legal definition of “gross negligence” or “wanton disregard for safety” required to support a third-party claim. Instead, the courts decide each case based on its own merits. Unless you have serious injuries and proof of your employer’s gross negligence, do not pursue a lawsuit.
Third-party actions require proof of serious injuries, such as fractures, head trauma, serious burns, scarring and second- or third-degree burns. Soft tissue injuries like pulled muscles, minor burns, abrasions and contusions aren’t enough. No matter how upset with a coworker or your employer you might be, without proof of gross negligence and serious injuries, your lawsuit won’t succeed.
Example: Burned by boiling grease
David worked for a fast food restaurant. He and several other employees noticed a coworker named Jason always seemed to be high on drugs. Jason’s primary job duties included use and maintenance of the restaurant’s grease fryer. At first David and his fellow workers didn’t particularly care about Jason’s drug use, but they began to notice he was making mistakes, such as setting the fryer at temperatures well above its safety limits.
David approached the manager and told him he and his coworkers feared Jason’s errors could cause a fire. The manager didn’t want to lose a worker, and he dismissed David’s warning as an overreaction. Despite his coworkers’ advice and assistance, Jason continued to make errors. David went back to the manager again and expressed the employees’ concerns. This time the manager said he would speak with Jason, but he never did.
One afternoon, Susan (another employee) was working with Jason when the grease fryer exploded. She was showered with boiling grease, sustaining third degree burns on her face and arms. Susan filed a workers’ compensation claim, which paid her medical bills, out-of-pocket expenses, and two-thirds of her wages while she was recovering.
Susan also retained an attorney and filed a third-party lawsuit against the owner of the fast food restaurant. In her lawsuit, Susan claimed the manager’s failure to take corrective action rose above negligence, constituting gross negligence and a wanton disregard for her safety.
The court ruled in Susan’s favor and ordered the owner to pay Susan’s medical bills, out-of-pocket expenses, all her lost wages, and a substantial amount for her pain and suffering. Further, the court said the restaurant owner’s failure to properly supervise his manager’s actions merited an award of punitive damages. (Punitive damages are in addition to pain and suffering and are usually many times higher.)
Reimbursing Workers’ Compensation
Third-party lawsuits can take months or years before they settle or go to trial. In the meantime, workers’ compensation benefits may pay for medical bills and expenses. By law, when an injured employee receives an award from a lawsuit for those same injuries, he must reimburse the workers’ comp insurance company for its payments.
A third-party award is generally higher than the worker’s comp payments. The injured worker can keep the difference between the amount workers’ comp paid, and the amount he receives in settlement (minus attorney’s fees, if applicable).
The Role of Attorneys
You probably don’t need an attorney for your worker’s comp claim if you only sustained soft tissue injuries as a result of employee negligence. If your injuries are more serious and you believe they are disabling, you should seek the counsel of an experienced attorney as soon as possible.
You must retain legal representation if you decide to pursue a third-party claim against your employer. Only an experienced personal injury attorney has the knowledge and expertise required to build a successful case. They can conduct pretrial discovery and depositions, subpoena records, and even hire technical and medical experts.
Most workers’ comp and personal injury attorneys don’t charge for initial office consultations. If an attorney accepts your case, you won’t have to pay any legal fees in advance. You only pay if and when your attorney settles, or wins your case at trial.
How Much is Your Injury Claim Worth?
Find out now with a FREE case review from an attorney…
Visitor Questions on Common Causes of Work Injuries
Search for a Previously Answered Question
I had a severe injury at work. The operator of the machine didn’t set it up correctly. A piece broke while the machine was operating and took my hand almost completely off. It was only connected by one tendon. I had 4 surgeries to have everything reconstructed so far. My work didn’t lock out the... Read More >>
My dishwasher hurt an employee’s finger and he told me that he was in pain, so he had to go see a doctor. After he went to see the doctor he brought a work release form to me. The doctor said he can’t be lifting heavy things for 3 days and may return to work... Read More >>
My writing hand was smashed between a loading ramp and a bob cat while I was chaining the loading ramp to a truck (conex) for safety. A co-worker not paying attention to where he was driving pushed the ramp into the conex with my hand in between, crushing and mangling my hand. As a result... Read More >>
I was training a co-worker on a piece of heavy equipment and he was injured. I have no certifications to train other than 10 years of heavy equipment operations. My employer has made a statement to me that there is no way that I can be sued, but I’m still wondering if I can be... Read More >>
As I was in training out in the field with my supervisor talking to me in my right ear (it was noisy) when another employee ran from behind me and jumped up in the air off my back – horseplay. I went down to the left and to brace my fall I used my left... Read More >>
I work in a kitchen as a cook at an assisted living facility. Yesterday January 29th, 2012 while at work I stepped on a piece of glass that was left on the floor by my boss when he had knocked a glass cup off the counter. Instead of picking it up when it happened he... Read More >>
My coworker and I were walking down the hall together. She was carrying a cup of hot water from the coffee pot which she was taking to her desk to make tea. We bumped into each other and the water caused a 2nd degree burn on my arm and a very large scar that is... Read More >>
I make car batteries at my job. A table of batteries was turned on by another worker right when I was removing the wire from them. My co-worker made a mistake but I paid for it. I couldn’t use my arm for about three weeks. I now have headaches and still have some weakness in... Read More >>
At work one day my co-worker came up to me and started play fighting with me. I was on the phone at the time and to get him to knock it off I went to kick his buttocks (jokingly). As I kicked he put out his hand to block it and I ended up kicking... Read More >>
I work on a drilling rig. I was up in the derrick (about 130 feet from the ground) and my driller picked up the top drive and didn’t pay any attention. I wasn’t out of the way and I was squeezed between the top drive and the derrick. I had a muscle contusion, fractured my... Read More >>
I tripped walking due to someone else pushing a cart down an aisle at work and started to fall, catching myself and jammimg my hand on the belt line, causing my wrist to fracture. They are treating me pretty good and found a job for me that you can use one arm. My question is,... Read More >>
In November 2008, I was doing my job at a warehouse store distribution center. I was labeling product when another employee on an EPJ (electric pallet jack), ran into the pallets and my right foot was caught between the two stacks of pallets. I have since had three surgeries on my foot, trying to correct... Read More >>