Under normal circumstances, if you’re injured at work, workers’ compensation insurance will cover your medical bills, medications, transportation costs, and other reasonable out-of-pocket expenses. It should also cover about two-thirds of your lost wages. You may even get a lump sum settlement if you become disabled. In case of death, the benefits go to your surviving dependents.
When Employer Liabilty Begins and Ends
To be eligible for workers’ comp insurance benefits, a worker must be injured while “within the scope of their employment,” also referred to as “on the job,” or “on the clock.” So what does this include?
Defining the beginning and end of the work day is crucial in a workers’ comp claim. On-the-job activity can overlap with personal activities, making the lines hard to determine. Questions of liability are often raised when injuries occur during the commute to or from work, in parking lots, or at non-scheduled work activities.
Most states follow the “while in the course of employment” rule. The rule basically states that regardless of an employee’s physical location or the time of day she’s injured, if performing assigned job duties, the injury is considered a work place accident and is covered by workers’ compensation. While this rule seems clear, it remains the subject of thousands of legal disputes each year.
What’s Not Covered
Most states exclude injuries when a worker is traveling between home and work. This is often referred to as the “going or coming” rule, or as the U.S. Department of Labor calls it, the “portal to portal” rule. Under the portal to portal rule, workers’ comp coverage doesn’t begin until the employee arrives at his workplace. It ends when the he leaves at the end of his work day; but there are numerous exceptions.
Exceptions to the Portal to Portal Rule
1. Benefit to the Employer
A worker may be covered if he is injured commuting to or from work, when he is required to be away from his workplace or home to perform work duties that directly benefit his employer.
Example: Car Accident After Client Dinner
Adrian is a salesperson for a national corporation. Her primary job entails traveling to various states in her region to support customer relations. She usually flies into each city, checks into a hotel, and rents a car to travel back and forth to customers’ businesses.
One evening after dining with a client, Adrian was driving back to her hotel when a car ran a red light and crashed into her rental car. She was seriously injured in the accident. Although Adrian was commuting back and forth to her temporary home, she was covered by workers’ compensation. She was injured while performing duties that directly benefited her employer.
There is an exception to this exception. If Adrian had been arrested and convicted of driving while intoxicated, she would not be covered. Workers’ compensation does not extend to workers who are injured while committing a crime, and a conviction for DUI is a crime. In most cases this would be true whether the employee’s impaired state contributed to the accident or not.
2. Special Missions
A worker may be covered if he is injured commuting to or from work, when he interrupts his normal route to conduct a work task or special mission required by his employer.
Example: Slip and Fall While Running an Errand
Jodi works at a law firm. Her normal lunch hour is from noon to 1:00 p.m. Her employer asked if she would stop by the court house on her way back from lunch to file some legal documents with the court clerk. Jodi agreed. She stopped at the courthouse at 12:45 p.m. on her way back from lunch. While walking up the courthouse steps, Jodi slipped and fell, breaking her arm.
Even though Jodi was on her lunch hour, the detour to the court house was a “special mission” for her employer. From the moment Jodi pointed her car to the courthouse, through the time she returned to the law firm’s offices, she was within the scope of her employment. Jodi’s injury on the courthouse steps is considered to be a work place accident and is therefore covered by workers’ compensation.
3. Sidewalks and Parking Lots
In most cases, workers’ compensation coverage begins when an employee starts his workday by stepping onto his employer’s premises or an area controlled by his employer. It ends when a worker steps off his employer’s premises or an area controlled by his employer.
The term “controlled by” refers to property an employer either owns outright, pays a mortgage on, pays property taxes on, pays a third party (like landscapers) to maintain, or is designated as a common area for which the employer contributes rent along with other tenants.
An area controlled by an employer is considered an extension of the worker’s actual workplace. Examples of areas controlled by employers include sidewalks, grassy areas, parking lots, and any other property a worker traverses on his way to and from his actual workplace.
Example: Hit in a Parking Lot
Charlie is a cashier in a large grocery store. Management requires employees to park their cars at the rear of the parking lot so shoppers can use the main area in front of the store. One evening, as he crossed the store’s lot to leave work, Charlie was struck by a car backing out of its parking space. He was seriously injured.
Even though Charlie had punched out and left the grocery store, he’s covered by workers’ comp because the parking lot is under his employer’s control. His employer knew that Charlie had to traverse the parking lot to get to his car, and it is an “extension” of the grocery store.
Charlie also has a valid third-party claim against the driver of the car. He can sue the negligent driver for his injuries and resulting damages, including pain and suffering. (Workers’ comp doesn’t cover pain and suffering.)
4. Outside of Regular Business Hours
When a worker’s duties include a responsibility that falls outside of regular business hours, and the worker is injured while performing that duty, workers compensation normally covers injuries sustained during that time.
Example: Car Crash While Speaking with a Patient
Raquel is a nurse who works for a doctor’s private medical practice. Her employer wants someone to always be available to his patients, so business calls are forwarded to Raquel’s cell phone after the office closes.
Raquel was driving home one evening when her cell phone rang. It was one of the doctor’s patients. As she began to speak with the patient, Raquel dropped the phone, which caused her to momentarily take her eyes off the road. She crashed and was seriously injured.
Even though Raquel was negligent, she was still discharging her work duties while in the scope of her employment. This qualifies as a work place accident and is covered by workers’ comp. The same principle extends to business professionals who talk with clients on their cell phones while driving to and from work (if speaking with clients is part of their work duties).
5. After-Hours Visits to the Workplace
One of the more controversial coverage issues involves employees who aren’t scheduled to work, but come to the workplace to visit with coworkers or for other personal matters. In most cases, employees who aren’t scheduled to work are not covered by workers’ compensation if injured on work premises.
On the other hand, if the employer is aware that unscheduled workers come to the workplace to visit with coworkers, and the employer tacitly consents to the visits by not objecting, workers’ comp may be forced to provide coverage when a non-scheduled employee is injured on the premises.
Example: Basketball During Lunch Break
Steven works at a warehouse and is friends with several coworkers. They are on a company-sponsored basketball team and play against other local businesses’ employee basketball teams. Most days the workers practice during their lunch break on a basketball court their employer set up in a corner of the warehouse.
Steven wasn’t scheduled to work one day, but he wanted to practice for an upcoming game. Steven’s employer knew non-scheduled workers would come in some days to practice. Steven came and was injured during the practice game.
Although it was lunch hour, the accident happened on a court provided for employee recreation during their break. The employer knew his employees frequently came to the workplace on their days off to practice, and he never objected. His failure to object to Steven’s off-hours presence effectively validates it as a work place accident and makes Steven eligible to receive workers’ compensation benefits.
Workers’ Comp Attorneys
Many employers and their workers’ comp insurance companies will deny legitimate claims. They’ll say an injury isn’t work related because it happened off the employer’s property, while the worker was on break, or because the worker wasn’t acting within the scope of his employment.
If your work injury claim is denied based on these issues, you may want to consider speaking with an attorney with experience in work place accident claims. This is especially true if your injury falls within one of the exceptions listed above. Most workers’ comp attorneys do not charge for initial office consultations. They only receive a fee if they succeed in winning you a settlement or a court award.
Auto Mechanic Injured While Not on Shift
Do workers comp benefits still apply if an employee is covering another worker’s shift? What about if the employee is volunteering their time? These are some of the legal issues addressed in this case study.
How Much is Your Injury Claim Worth?
Find out now with a FREE case review from an attorney…
Visitor Questions on Issues with Work Injury Claims
Search for a Previously Answered Question
This last weekend a friend of mine was injured by falling off a ladder in an RV park. He has 2 compression fractures in his back and a mild concussion. He fell off the ladder while he was working off the clock in a secure stable work location that was locked. He had only been... Read More.
I had arrived at work, but left the office to go to the restaurant next door to buy breakfast. I slipped on ice and injured my shoulder in the parking lot. I went to the hospital and received treatment. I was unable to work the rest of the day and part of the following day.... Read More.
I was cleaning my desk out after being terminated, and when leaving the office I was carrying a paper box with items from my desk. I went down the stairs because the elevator is very slow and I was embarrassed and didn’t want to interact with my previous coworkers. I tripped on the third step... Read More.
The construction company that I work for is currently attempting to deny hours for driving the Commercial Drivers License (CDL) truck from the worksite to an offsite location, and vise versa, before and after work. If I’m “off the clock” driving that commercial vehicle to the offsite location, who is responsible for an accident that... Read More.
There was a huge crack and heave in the cement sidewalk immediately in front of the entrance to work. It ran the entire length of the entranceway and was there for 6 – 8 weeks. There was a 3″ elevation and heave that was tripped over by many, but I was the one who actually... Read More.
I work for a Home Health Agency agency, for which I go to clients’ homes and provide care. I go to several clients per day. I arrived at my first location and when I stepped out of my car I fell on ice at the client’s home (in their driveway). I had not clocked in... Read More.
I do not have to punch in and out for lunch, but I do not get paid for lunch. I left during my lunch break to get something for lunch when I was injured. I slipped and fell as I was getting out of my car at a Subway, which is across the street. I... Read More.
I walked into a glass door entering the store where I work and suffered facial damage. The company is planning to controvert it because they rent the space from another store. (My company rents space for a small boutique located inside a different company’s store.) Would it be considered “on the property” if the accident... Read More.
After a full day shift I clocked out, but then my General Manager at the airport told me to unload all of the bags off the aircraft and take the bags to the baggage claim. I advised her that my shift was over a half hour ago, and that I was clocked out, and that... Read More.
I was with a group from work on the way to a job-sponsored charitable event. We stopped at a restaurant to grab a bite, while still on the clock. As we entered, something blew up, causing me to be struck by flying debris. I went to the emergency room and was x-rayed and received pain... Read More.
Me and my friend had finished our shift and clocked out for the night. When I got in my car to leave work I discovered my battery was dead. I asked my friend if he could help me jump my car. While in the process, I had the car in gear and when the car... Read More.
I work swing shifts as a paramedic. While I was off there was some construction done on the inside of the building. There was a concrete wheel stop that was moved from the inside of the building to the outside. This wheel stop was not painted nor did it have any distinctive markings. There were... Read More.
I was jogging at a park when I fainted and needed medical attention. My question is, will/should my work insurance cover the costs of my medical bills? Additional information: my job title is computer technician. It’s indoor work. In the past 5 years “other duties assigned” include outside physical duties which I have expressed concern... Read More.
I fell on the ice right outside our school building in the breezeway. My principal says now that I am not covered by workers’ compensation. When she took me to the doctor right after the fall, a CT scan or MRI was never done. She says the school or workers’ compensation will not be responsible... Read More.
I cut my finger while I was on my lunch break at work. My breaks are broken down into two 15 minute breaks which I am paid for, and a 30 minute lunch break in which I am not paid for. If it happens that this finger gets infected, can I file I workmans’ comp... Read More.
A worker parked at an adjacent parking lot because it has provided closer access to the front entrance to the building. We have in times past secured permission for a certain number of workers to use these parking spaces. However, during winter a worker stepped over a mound of ice and snow that bordered the... Read More.
On January 16th, 2014 I was leaving the school building walking to my car. The parking lot is school property, and had about 2-3″ of snow on top of ice (not plowed or salted). When I reached my car I slipped and fell to my knees, and then to my hands. Some coworkers helped me... Read More.
I reside in Massachusetts and I slipped on black ice in the parking lot at work. I needed medical attention which led to an overnight stay for observation at the hospital. My employer leases half the building. Do I need to make a claim for hospital bills, etc. from the owner of the building? Can... Read More.
I work for a park reserve in Illinois. We sleep on the premises sometimes. I chose to sleep there this night as the job was to clear snow with snow plows. I wanted to make sure at least I was able to get out and plow when my shift started. There has never been a... Read More.
My company required me to drive from home to another work location at the local convention center here in town. I work as a security officer and our main office is at another location. When I arrived to work the convention, I tripped and fell in the parking lot twisting my ankle. I didn’t feel... Read More.
The parking lot outside my workplace was icy and I fell and got a concussion. I have been getting headaches, dizzyness and nausea for days. I got a CT Scan and there was no bleeding or fractures in my skull. My work said they would cover the days missed from work and cost of the... Read More.
I was hurt off the job at an employer-provided house for contracted employees. After getting off work and returning to the house (in North Dakota) I fell coming up the house’s steps to the porch that had no hand rails and were covered by snow and ice. When I fell I shattered parts of my... Read More.
I am a civilian federal employee in Aberdeen, Maryland who was walking to my car after my work day had concluded. I cut across a grassy area that separated two paved areas of the parking lot. While walking across this grassy area I stepped in a hole and my knee hyperextended, causing a torn MCL.... Read More.
As I was leaving work I tripped/stumbled on an area of the sidewalk that was higher than the surrounding areas and that had a wide expansion joint. I fractured my wrist from the fall, resulting in surgery and 4 months out of work. The workers comp insurer would not pay claim stating that the sidewalk... Read More.
I was walking out to my car when I slipped on some ice in the driveway. I hit my head on the edge of some bricks when I fell and I ended up with 6 staples in my head. Now the insurance keeps denying the bills, stating that they are not work related. So my... Read More.
Last night while walking to my car from work at the hospital I fell and hurt myself quite severely. I had a similar injury about three or four years ago. The first time, I reported it to the hospital administration and they said it was a workers comp issue and sent me to occupational health... Read More.
I was leaving work at a large national chain retail electronics store, and while I was walking out I tripped over a parking stop that was not painted. I have lost money from my job due to this injury. I am currently on workers compensation but I have also lost a lot of income because... Read More.
I was walking on the pedestrian side of the handicapped parking lot at my work when I slipped and fell and landed on my left shoulder and hip. It’s been more than 5 days now and I haven’t seen by doctor due to worker’s compensation insurance taking so time. Meanwhile my hip has been bothering... Read More.
I broke my left arm at work. Right when I went on lunch break I went outside and then slipped on ice, falling and breaking my arm. I could have been an old lady and I could have died. Now my job is saying they found THC in my system and they are sticking me... Read More.
I worked my shift and had already clocked out. After clocking out I was walking out of the building and tripped and fell in the parking lot, fracturing my ankle. My question is: Can I file a workers compensation claim if I had already clocked out of work? Thanks. Read More.
I had finished working and clocked out. My truck battery was dead, so my boss jumped started my truck for me. It had been raining that day. The water was a little above ankle deep. After we got it started I jumped out of the truck and my knee bucked out from underneath me. He... Read More.
After I finished my shift at work I got hit by a car as a pedestrian. It happened just across from the hospital I work at. Can I claim from the other party’s insurance since I crossed on green light? There are people telling me that I can claim for workman’s compensation. What do you... Read More.
My adult son fell and broke his leg in 3 places with a compound fracture. After 3 hours of surgery they put a metal rod in his leg. He fell in a school parking lot on ice, on his way to work there. The doctor has him out of work, he is now on workman’s... Read More.
I had a slip and fall at work and don’t know what kind of case it is. Ice fell during the night and our company acknowledged a 2 hour delay to work. I got to work at 10:08 and parked my car. After coming out of the car walking to the building I slipped and... Read More.
I fell in the parking lot of my job when I was on my way to the car to go home. We had an ice storm the night before and the parking lot was not shoveled. I have a lumbar sprain and a pinched nerve and can no longer do my job. Can I sue... Read More.