Liability for Car Accident Wrongful Deaths



According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), car accidents kill more than 35,000 people in the United States each year. On average, there's one car accident death reported every 12 minutes.

While the number of car accidents has steadily risen over the past 10 years, the number resulting in death has steadily declined. This is due mainly to improved car safety features, including advanced restraint systems, new vehicle construction techniques, crumple zones, force-absorbing materials, and more. All this is limited comfort to you if your loved one has died in a fatal crash.

According to the American Automobile Association, the leading causes of fatal car accidents are:

  • Distracted drivers
  • Driver fatigue
  • Drunk and reckless driving
  • Weather conditions
  • Street and highway defects
  • Car manufacturing defects
  • Inexperienced and/or elderly drivers

Wrongful Death

One of the first questions family members ask is "Why?" Why did we lose our father, mother, son, or daughter suddenly and violently?

Putting aside the emotional, the answer often lies in determining if there was negligence. When the authorities decide that negligence caused a fatal car crash, the legal concept of wrongful death comes to the forefront. A wrongful death claim is a demand a family member or court designee makes on the party whose actions caused the person's death.

Today, every state has one form or another of a wrongful death statute. Under these statutes, a grieving party has the right to seek compensation for the loss of a loved one. Surviving family members commonly bring these legal actions, but sometimes court-designated trustees can bring them.

In a wrongful death suit, aggrieved (victimized) family members have the right to seek damages for the loss of their loved one. Each state's wrongful death laws set the type and amount of damages. While some states limit damages, others are more liberal.

For example, in Illinois, a jury may award surviving family members:

...as they shall deem a fair and just compensation with reference to the pecuniary injuries resulting from such death, including damages for grief, sorrow, and mental suffering, to the surviving spouse and next of kin of such deceased person."

In New York:

...the amount of damages determined by a court are what it deems to be fair and just compensation for pecuniary injuries resulting from the decedent's death. Damages include reasonable expenses for medical aid, nursing, and funeral expenses, in addition to every other lawful element."

Find your state's wrongful death law.

Proving Your Wrongful Death Claim

In wrongful death cases, the stakes are much higher than those in nonfatal personal injury claims. Proving a claim begins with three basic points.

1. You must prove someone or some entity was at fault.

For example, if the fatal car crash occurred when the decedent's car hit a large pothole and flipped over, you can perhaps prove the city or state was at fault, and negligent in not properly maintaining the road or highway.

Or if the fatal crash occurred due to an intoxicated driver, you can possibly prove that the bar owner who last served the driver violated the state's dram shop laws prohibiting serving alcohol to an already intoxicated patron.

2. A spouse, children, legal beneficiaries, or dependents survive the deceased.

You need to prove your relationship to the deceased. If the decedent was your spouse, you need a wedding license. For children, birth certificates will do. If you're a beneficiary named in the deceased's will, you need a copy of the will. If you're a beneficiary in an insurance policy, you need a copy of the policy.

3. The death of your loved one will result in a pecuniary (monetary) loss.

If the decedent worked at the time of his death and was the father of one or more children, you need proof of the amount of income he would have made during his lifetime. A jury can consider the decedent's earnings at the time of his or her death. If the decedent was unemployed at the time of death, the jury can consider the decedent's last known income and possible future income.

Comparative and Contributory Negligence

When considering any car accident death, it's vital to understand the legal application of comparative and contributory negligence.

Contributory Negligence

In states that adhere to the contributory negligence rule, surviving beneficiaries can't recover any damages if the decedent in any manner contributed to his or her own death. Many consider this rule extremely harsh.

Nonetheless, in those states that follow the contributory negligence doctrine, if a negligent party can raise the affirmative defense (new facts) proving the decedent even remotely acted in a way that contributed to his death, the decedent's surviving beneficiaries will receive nothing.

Let's say a driver ran a red light and crashed head-on into another vehicle, killing the driver of the second car. If the driver who ran the red light can prove the decedent was texting on her cell phone or otherwise distracted, the surviving beneficiaries won't be eligible to receive any compensation.

Today, the states of Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia, and the District of Columbia follow the contributory negligence rule.

Comparative Negligence

The balance of states follow one of two forms of the comparative negligence rule. In these states, a negligent party can raise a defense stating the decedent was partially responsible for the car accident, and therefore partially responsible for his own death. The surviving beneficiaries will then receive a percentage of the final award corresponding to the percentage of the decedent's negligence.

Using the same example as above, if the negligent party can prove the decedent was texting or otherwise distracted at the time of the crash, the surviving beneficiaries will receive an award reduced by the percentage of the decedent's own negligence for texting. If the court rules the decedent's texting accounted for 20% of the cause of the crash, the family will only receive 80% of the total amount of compensation awarded.

Winning a Car Accident Fatality Case

Winning a wrongful death claim requires substantial credible evidence. Unlike minor soft tissue injury claims that you can handle yourself, wrongful deaths always require the expertise of a personal injury attorney with substantial experience in car accident fatality cases. There's just too much at stake in these cases. The sooner you hire an experienced attorney the better.

Experienced personal injury attorneys have the training and money it takes to thoroughly investigate and win the case. Hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars are at stake in fatality cases. Insurance companies will do everything they can to deny a claim outright. When that doesn't work, they'll try to deny it based on contributory negligence. They are also expert at devaluing claims based on comparative negligence, even where none exists.

Most attorneys hire investigators to quickly return to the scene of the crash to look for and measure skid marks, identify road flaws, take digitized close-ups of the most obscure evidence, and more. Investigators will drive to body shops and car storage facilities to do close-up examinations of the cars, all while looking for even a tiny amount of favorable evidence.

Attorneys will hire accident reconstruction specialists who use proprietary computer programs that can recreate in three dimensions the crash as it happened. In addition, attorneys can hire highly experienced forensic car crash experts whose knowledge of biomechanics is invaluable in winning the case.

When it comes to fatal car crash claims, most experienced attorneys will bypass the insurance company and immediately file a lawsuit. Doing so gives the attorney immediate access to records, witness statements, police reports, and more. Also, once he files a lawsuit, the attorney can take the depositions (recorded, sworn statements) of every person who knows anything about the crash, including the driver, their employers, passengers, and other parties.

Attorneys can subpoena video footage from traffic cameras, store surveillance cameras, and even from private individuals who may have taken photos of the crash or its aftermath. They can also secure court orders restraining insurance companies, individuals, and government agencies from destroying or erasing evidence related to the crash.

Most experienced personal injury attorneys fight as hard as possible to win their client's case. In fatal car crash cases, when attorneys often lay out thousands and even hundreds of thousands of dollars in pretrial preparation, they leave no stone unturned. These attorneys know their legal fees and costs are only reimbursed if they win your case. If they lose, they lose more than just the case; they lose all the time and money they put into it.

Statute of Limitations

The term statute of limitations refers to the amount of time your state allows to either settle your wrongful death claim or file a lawsuit. Missing that deadline means you lose all recourse to recover compensation for the loss of your loved one.

Each state has its own statutory period. Make sure you know that deadline. Keep in mind the limitation period in your state for filing a wrongful death suit may differ from the period for filing another type of personal injury suit.

Class Action Lawsuits

A class action is a lawsuit, normally filed against a large corporation, which includes a large number of people who were similarly and adversely affected by the company's negligence. Automobile manufacturers frequently issue recalls for vehicles that have dangerous defects or flaws. This usually occurs after one or more people are hurt or killed while riding in their car.

If a loved one was the victim of a fatal car crash and you believe a defective part in the car caused the accident, contact an attorney immediately. You can also go online to see if there already are any wrongful death class action lawsuits about the same defective car part. If the class action is still open to new plaintiffs, you can "opt-in." You can check class action cases at ClassAction.com.

Case Study:

Drinking and Driving Fatality
This case deals with the unfortunate consequences of driving under the influence. A woman dies and a man is paralyzed from the waste down. We'll examine issues of liability and compensation.

Print Friendly and PDF

How Much Is Your Claim Worth?

Find out now with a FREE case review from an attorney...

Ask a Car Accident Death Question

Unfortunately, we can only accept questions from the U.S.A. and we can't guarantee a response. Please proofread your submission, and DON'T WRITE IN ALL CAPS!

Disclaimer: Information provided in our response is NOT formal legal advice. It is generic legal information based on the very limited information provided. Under no circumstances should the information in our response, or anywhere else on this site be relied upon when deciding the proper course of a legal matter. Always get a formal case review from a licensed attorney.

Previous Questions & Answers...

Sister killed in car crash last year due to driver lack of experience... 
On October 29, 2015 my older sister, whom I lived and worked with, was killed by a driver who crossed into the next lane as my sister got out of the car, …

Homeless pedestrian killed... 
My brother was hit by a car while crossing the street at 11:00 at night in Florida. My brother was homeless and I was not aware of his whereabouts until …

Who are beneficiaries of insurance payout for my daughter's death? 
My daughter died in a car accident. She was a passenger. The driver also died and was under the influence. The driver had no car insurance. My daughter, …

Boyfriend died in accident where at-fault driver failed to yield... 
My boyfriend of eleven years was killed by a driver who Failed to Yield. He was 57 years old when he passed. He had one son that he had not seen for at …

My dad was killed by drunk driver... 
My dad was killed Wednesday from head-on collision with a drunk driver in Texas. She died too. I'm so confused right now and there is so much information …

Is a mother able to access death benefits received by daughter? 
My mother, my daughter and I were in a serious car accident which killed my mother. She had a great insurance policy in which my daughter, 6, was under …

Husband killed by a car while riding his bike to work... 
My husband was hit and killed by a car while he was riding his bike to work. He was moving out from the shoulder of the road to the left side of the lane …

Killed en route to job site... 
My brother was killed in a single car accident on his way to a job site. He was a construction worker and drove a company vehicle to and from various job …

Can criminal charges be filed? 
My niece was involved in a car accident on January 25, 2015, she died due to the accident. She was a passenger in the vehicle. The driver of the vehicle …

Paying taxes on uninsured motorist accident settlement? 
My mother was killed in a car accident caused by an uninsured driver. My father is now getting a sizable settlement from his auto insurance company based …

Death of dementia patient... 
My mother was killed when my stepfather pulled to the center area of a 6 lane busy highway and told my mother to get out of the truck to throw up. She …

Car Passenger Liability? 
This is more of a scenario that my son and I have been debating, not an actual situation, but we are trying to obtain guidance... Let's say my 21 year …

Son hit and killed while mowing grass for employer... 
My son worked for a landscaping company. He was riding a large stand up mower, blowing grass off the street, when he was struck by a car and killed instantly. …

Killed while changing a flat tire... 
I have a question about my daughter's father who was killed in a traffic accident in Alabama. The decedent was changing a flat tire when he was hit by …

Is 28 years too late to pursue a wrongful death case? 
My dad was killed in a car accident 28 years ago. I was six months old at the time. He was driving to work when another vehicle crossed the center line …

Cut out of award money after mother killed in head-on car wreck... 
My mother was killed in head-on car wreck in Oregon. My father hired an attorney and a wrongful death case was filed, but for only $100,000.00 dollars!! …

Truck Driver Killed in Rear End Accident... 
While my Dad was driving in his company truck on the interstate, another trucker pulled out of the emergency lane at about 15 mph in front of my dad, causing …

Motorcycle Passenger Killed in Accident... 
Myself and a passenger were riding on my motorcycle when a car pulled out in front of us. I was unable to stop and hit the car on the drivers side door. …

Mother Hit by a Car and Killed... 
My mom died last year after getting hit by a woman driving her car. My mom was in the hospital fighting for her life for 5 hours. She suffered several …

Lawsuit Against the City for Car Crash Deaths... 
My son and his friends all passed away in a car crash. The city came in and repaved street that the accident occurred on while the accident was still under …

Serious Car Accident Results in Fatality... 
My daughter was allowed to drive without a license by my ex-wife. She was in a serious car accident and was killed. I feel my ex-wife is responsible for …

Killed by a driver who fell asleep at the wheel... 
My father was hit and killed by a truck driver who fell asleep at the wheel. The driver admitted he fell asleep. My father had broken down on the side …

Claim Involving Automobile Accident Deaths... 
I was in a roll over car accident in 1994 involving myself and the automobile accident deaths of my family members. My oldest sister and her oldest son …

How Much for a Wrongful Death? 
I was inquiring about the average settlement for a wrongful death case. My brother and future sister in law both passed away due to the motor vehicle accident. …

Click here to write your own.

Death of a motorcycle driver... 
I was driving in a truck hauling furniture in the back when the rope and cord broke, causing a piece of the furniture to fall in the road. I called 911 …

Wrongful Death Jurisdiction and Question of Liability 
Our son was in a car accident in Missouri, we live in Wisconsin. One young man was killed in the accident. Our son was not the driver, and we do not own …

Click here to write your own.

> > Car Accident Wrongful Deaths

How Much Are Your
Injuries Worth?

Find out with a
free attorney review:

TYPE OF ACCIDENT
AUTO ACCIDENT
PERSONAL INJURY
WORKERS COMPENSATION
MEDICAL ERROR
YES! I WANT FAIR COMPENSATION