According to the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, a car accident occurs once every 60 seconds. That’s almost 6 million a year. Of those, almost one-third involve multi-vehicle accidents, also called multi-vehicle collisions or pile-ups.
All it takes is one driver who’s distracted for a moment to set off a massive chain reaction of cars, trucks, travel trailers, motorcycles, and other vehicles, all crashing into each other. With thousands of pounds of glass and metal flying about, the probability of serious injuries and death from multi-vehicle collisions is high.
Multi-vehicle collisions are notoriously more deadly than two-car collisions. In multi-vehicle accidents, several cars can hit one car several times from several different directions. Each vehicle involved means a greater and greater amount of broken glass, bent steel, and leaking gasoline. The possibility of fire is always a concern. If passengers can’t get out of their vehicles, there’s a chance they may burn to death or suffocate from lack of oxygen.
Those passengers who can get out of their vehicles are often in shock. They may be oblivious to other cars whizzing by only a few feet away from them. Moreover, because multi-car collisions often result in blocked roadways, it’s often difficult for fire and rescue vehicles to get to the crash site quickly.
Common Causes of Multi-Vehicle Accidents
There are multiple causes of multi-vehicle collisions. Some of the most common are:
Bad weather conditions often result in low visibility and slippery roads. Snow, ice, rain, fog, and smog are just some of the conditions that can quickly turn an otherwise safe road into a hazardous one. This is especially true on highways with high speed limits.
Airbags, heavy insulation, loud stereo systems, and engines that propel 2,000-pound cars from 0 to 60 in four seconds give drivers a false sense of security. At high speed, one wrong turn of the wheel or one slower car in front of another faster one can set off a chain reaction of bent steel, broken glass, and serious injuries.
When a driver falls asleep, even for a split second, there’s no one driving the car; it’s driverless although the driver’s foot may still press the gas pedal. It only takes a second for a driverless car to drift into another lane, careen off the road, or plow into the car in front.
Intoxicated drivers aren’t just the stereotypical, “I’ve had one too many” drivers. They also include drivers with altered perception under the influence of legal and illegal drugs. The side effects of many prescription drugs include drowsiness and altered time and depth perception.
No list of causes for multi-vehicle accidents is complete without including cell phones. Talking, texting, taking photographs, and checking email are some of the leading causes of collisions. Unfortunately, the majority of those cell phones distract young people. Many feel invincible and immune to the terrible destruction their distraction may cause.
High-speed police chases have frequently caused collisions. Although many cities now have restricted police chases to crimes involving serious felonies, there are still instances of police officers or the people they’re chasing losing control of their vehicles or other vehicles striking them during a chase.
Car stereo systems turned up so high the drivers can’t hear emergency vehicles is a common cause of accidents. Also, conversations with passengers, reading maps, eating, putting on makeup, and general boredom/inattention can also lead to accidents.
Determining Fault in a Multi-Vehicle Pile-up
Multi-vehicle accidents often involve extremely high insurance payouts. This is especially true when accidents occur on high-speed roadways and involve four, five, or more vehicles. In these types of cases, the amount of insurance money at stake climbs quite high.
As a result, insurance companies normally assign trained accident investigators to the claim. Because at-fault drivers will seldom freely admit responsibility, it’s necessary for the investigators to find the underlying cause and the responsible driver.
Duty of Care and Proximate Cause
Determining fault in a multi-car collision is a complex process. Each driver has a duty of care (responsibility) to the other drivers. That duty of care is to drive reasonably and prudently (carefully) under the circumstances. Not exercising this duty of care is sometimes a willful or negligent act.
When one driver’s willful or negligent act becomes the direct and proximate (legally acceptable) cause of injuries to another driver, the injured driver has a legal right to compensation from the at-fault driver.
The more vehicles in the accident the greater the degree of difficulty the authorities have in identifying the negligent act. Who was speeding? Who was following too closely? Who was on a cell phone? Were there mitigating (explanatory) circumstances? Was there more than one negligent driver? And the list goes on.
To determine fault, investigators will:
- Review police reports and speak with investigating officers. The accident investigators are especially interested in knowing whether the police arrested or ticketed any driver for:
– Outstanding warrants
– Intoxication (alcohol or drugs)
– Open alcohol container
– Possession of narcotics
– Suspended license or unlicensed driver
– No insurance
– Failure to yield right of way
– Following too closely
– Reckless driving
- Interview the drivers, their passengers, and other witnesses
- Take photographs of the vehicles and the accident scene, including skid marks, damaged trees, guardrails, fences, etc.
- Review the drivers’ driving records looking for prior arrests, tickets, accidents, etc.
Local Multi-Vehicle Accidents at Intersections
Multi-vehicle collisions aren’t restricted to high-speed thoroughfares. Many occur locally at slower speeds. Intersections especially are hot spots for low speed multi-car accidents. One driver may stop at a red light only to have the driver behind him skid on an ice patch right into him. The second driver may push the first into the intersection, and then a car going through the intersection sideswipes it.
Comparative and Contributory Negligence
Fault can spread among several vehicles, including yours. Because most states follow the comparative negligence rule, each driver can receive compensation according to his percentage of fault. In those few states that follow the contributory negligence rule, any driver who has any fault may not receive any compensation.
Mitigation or Elimination of Fault
In some cases, the authorities recognize mitigating or eliminating circumstances. Although most multi-car collisions are a result of someone’s negligence, there are those few occasions when no one is to blame.
For example, on a snowy day, each car is driving cautiously and safely when one hits an ice patch and slams into another car, which, in turn, crashes into another and so on. Or, a driver may have struck another car after losing consciousness from a heart attack or other serious malady. In these cases, it’s difficult or impossible to assess fault.
Filing Your Own Claim Against the At-fault Driver(s)
If you’re in a multi-vehicle accident, contact your insurance company. If your insurance isn’t no-fault, you may want to pursue your own claim against the at-fault driver(s). For this, you need evidence of fault. If fault isn’t easily apparent, you can use the same investigative techniques the insurance company investigators do.
If you’re not sure who was at fault, you can file your claim against all the other driver’s insurance companies. In turn, they may help by doing some of the investigative work for you. To protect themselves, each company may produce evidence of lack of fault for their insured. However, they may decide to fight it out among themselves. Then, you can wait to see where the chips (evidence) fall and go from there.
Unfortunately, many multi-vehicle collisions end up in litigation (court or other legal processes). Because this kind of collision normally results in multiple claims for compensation, without clear evidence of fault, most insurance companies refuse to settle.
If the other drivers decide to point their fingers at each other or at you, it’s probably time to see a personal injury attorney . Most won’t charge for an initial visit.
How Much is Your Injury Claim Worth?
Find out now with a FREE case review from an attorney…
Visitor Questions on Multi-vehicle Collisions
Claim from multiple parties exceeds insurance coverage? I was parked legally in front of a quiet neighborhood and my truck was struck. I was not in the vehicle at the time. The motorist then struck another truck after mine, and finally ended by crashing into wall. There were several witnesses and a police report was filed. My question is, since my truck was... Read More >>
Driver’s insurance refuses to pay? I was involved in a three car crash. My car was waiting at a red light. When it turned green the lady behind me hit my car. The lady claimed the car behind her hit her so hard that she went forward and hit me. The lady was told by the guy behind to pull... Read More >>
Multi-car accident without adequate insurance coverage… I was involved in a 3 car accident where one of the drivers accepted fault, but his insurance only covers $10,000 for the accident as a whole. The other car was totaled and my car suffered almost $2000 worth of damages. Since the amount exceeds their insured’s policy, the insurance company is not willing to... Read More >>
Insurance denying liability in multiple car collision? I was hit first in left lane by a car. The car forced my car forward and over three lanes. The car that hit me started flipping after it hit me, causing traffic to stop in the middle lanes. My car moved to the right and forward. Once I was in the right lane, a... Read More >>
Cited for improper lane change resulting in a 4 car pile up? As I was approaching behind a car in the far left lane of a 3 lane intersection, the light was green. The car was approximately 100 yards from the light and driving rather slowly. There were no cars in front of her. The center lane had approximately 6 cars in the lane. As I approached... Read More >>
Rear ended at a red light, but at-fault driver has limited coverage… I was rear ended by a pick up truck when stopped at a red light. The driver of the pick up must have hit me pretty hard, as my car ended up hitting the car in front of me, so it ended up being a 3 car collision. I have an attorney and filed a... Read More >>
Separate accidents, but one indirectly caused the other? It was a rainy day and the roads were wet. On a busy two lane road everyone was going between 30-40mph. I was in a car in the left lane. A couple cars ahead of me there were two trucks. One of the trucks tried to cut the other truck off, causing the truck in... Read More >>
Multiple rear end collisions… The car in front of me came to an abrupt stop. She said that someone in front of her stopped for no apparent reason. I stood on my brakes and was stopping when I was rear ended and the impact caused me to crash into the car in front of me. I initially had ankle... Read More >>
Pile up classified as 2 separate accidents, car totaled? I came up a hill at green light, and my speed was at or slightly below the 45mph limit. Suddenly I saw red flashing rear hazard lights and a few people, realized they were in my lane, not in the middle, turning lane. I hit my brakes hard, and hit the 2nd car with the... Read More >>
I was in a 3 car accident but the first driver has no insurance? I was in a 3 car accident. I was the 3rd car. The first car slid out through a stop sign and hit the 2nd car from behind, and that person veered into my lane and hit me head on. The first person that caused the accident does not have a drivers license and has... Read More >>
Insurance refusing to pay because I’d already hit another vehicle? I live in Phoenix, AZ. I was driving to work going 70 mph down the freeway when all of a sudden the car in front of me slammed on their brakes & came to a complete stop. I slammed on my breaks, but hit them. My airbags deployed. I was stunned for a few minutes.... Read More >>
Liability in four car pile-up? I was in a 4-car accident. I was the 4th car, the third car which is in front of me stopped completely, hitting the second car in front of him, which then hit car 1 that was in front of it. Car number 2 said that he thinks car 3 fell asleep which caused him... Read More >>
Multiple parked cars damaged… Multiple parked cars were damaged in a Walmart parking lot. A person came and hit a total of 7 cars. My car was brand new, bought 4 days back. I paid $3000 as a down payment and had the remaining $15,500 on finance. I have collision and uninsured/underinsured coverage in my policy. The person who... Read More >>
Middle car not at-fault, but blamed for damages in 3 car pile up? I was in a 3 car pile up on the highway. I was car #2. Car #1 [in front] stopped short as another car cut him off. There was no impact there, that random car, continued driving. I hit my brakes as I wanted to avoid hitting car #1. I stopped just before making impact... Read More >>
Driver who lost control of her vehicle in icy conditions is blaming us? My wife and I were traveling southbound in heavy traffic on I-15 during icy conditions. We were traveling in the far right lane getting ready to take the upcoming exit. A young girl approximately 50 yards ahead and three lanes to our left lost control of her vehicle. Not knowing where she would end up,... Read More >>
Rear ended in multiple car collision… I was driving on a Two Lane highway that runs for 27 miles through the mountains that divides San Jose from Santa Cruz in California. This highway is notorious for accidents and just this year we have had two fatalities, both in slippery weather from the micro-climate found in this area. The highway speed limit... Read More >>
What happens when several drivers have partial liability? My Aunt and I were involved in a multi car (4) accident on the freeway during rush hour. A big rig swerved, supposedly to miss a car that pulled out in front of her (the big rig), it in turn caused another car to get pushed into myself, and I was pushed into the middle... Read More >>
Firetruck caused multi-car collision? I was involved in a 3-car accident, with one of those vehicles being a firetruck. After exiting a freeway and coming to a complete stop at a 4-way intersection, another car on my right came to a complete stop. I proceeded to enter the intersection heading straight, then I heard the siren of the firetruck... Read More >>
Car Accident Insurance Problem in Multiple Car Pile Up… I was involved in a multiple car collision. I was driving on the highway when the lead car’s driver slammed on the brakes, causing the car in front of me to rear-end the lead car and myself to rear-end the second car. The car behind me then rear-ended my car. The first car fled the... Read More >>
Defendant in a Personal Injury Lawsuit… I’m being sued by a plaintiff with whom I was involved in a 3 car collision (for no less than $300,000 including attorney fees). I hit one person from the rear then that person ended up hitting someone else that was in front them. My insurance company rescinded on the policy stating that I wasn’t... Read More >>
Liability in 3 Car Pile Up? I was driving on the highway when the lead car slammed on it’s brakes, causing the car in front of me to rear end the lead car and myself to rear end the second car. In short, I was the last car in a 3 car pile up. However the person in the lead car... Read More >>
Rear Ended at a Red Light… I was waiting at a red light with a car in front of me. A car hit me from behind. He was probably going fairly fast because when he hit me he made me slide into the car in front of me. The guy who rear ended me has no insurance. Both cars (the one... Read More >>
Liability in Multi Car Rear End Pile Up? A lady was driving 2 cars in front of me, down a 2 way street. A van was directly in front of me. There were cars on the right side of the street parallel parked. I was doing about 25mph right after a stop sign, tailing the white company van, without sight of the lady... Read More >>
Cited in a 3 Car Collision… I was in a car accident where the first two cars hit first and then I hit the 2nd car in line last. The first two cars were stuck together (rear bumper of the 1st car was stuck to the front bumper of the 2nd car). I had a scratch on my bumper but the... Read More >>
Kids in a Rear End Car Accident… Our nanny was taking my 3 kids home from their doctor appointment when a car behind hit a UPS truck and the UPS truck rear-ended the nanny’s car. The car’s rear two windows were broken and it has a big dent, the kids seemed OK until tonight. The youngest is 6 years old and she... Read More >>
Four Car Pile Up on the Highway… I was recently in a 4 car pile up wreck on the highway in Texas. What happened is that the guy who caused the whole wreck didn’t properly attach a trailer to his hitch on his truck and it fell off on the highway; the second car hit the trailer back into the first guys... Read More >>
Should I see my auto insurance adjuster in person? I was involved in a multiple car accident. I was not at fault, the driver who caused the 5 car accident was intoxicated. He was uninsured and did not have a valid license. I am filing my claims through my own insurance carrier. I talked to them on the phone about my personal injury and... Read More >>
Who Is Liable in Multiple Car Pile Ups? I was rear ended at a red light in a 4 car pile up. The last driver didn’t stop and struck one car which struck another and then struck me. I was in the front so I was only hit from behind. Who’s insurance will pay for the damages done to my truck and also... Read More >>