Insurance companies spend millions of dollars each year investigating and prosecuting fake injury claims. While a fair number of fraudulent claims slip through, companies catch and deny many more. Some of the most serious cases of fraud wind up in criminal courts.
Unfortunately, honest, hard-working people end up paying for the sins of others. Insurance companies simply pass on the costs of investigating fraudulent claims to their customers, in the form of higher premiums.
In this section, we look at what you can do to prevent your insurance company from paying a fake injury claim filed against you. Let’s begin by looking at how insurance companies classify fraudulent claims.
Categories of Fraud
- Hard fraud is serious. It occurs when one or more people stage accidents, or when they conspire to invent circumstances resulting in real or feigned injuries. Insurance companies and the police take this very seriously. This type of fraud has civil and criminal penalties.
- Soft fraud is more common. It occurs most often in legitimate claims, when claimants exaggerate their injuries to run up their damages. Claimants can also fake an injury by falsely using a prior injury as the basis for a new claim.
Fake injury claims aren’t limited to vehicle collisions. People also file them on alleged slip and fall accidents, defective products, assaults, dog bites, work accidents, medical errors, and more.
It’s virtually impossible to stop a dishonest person from filing a fraudulent claim. All he needs is some basic evidence of the accident, your name, and your insurance company’s phone number. But, there’s a big difference between filing a claim and actually getting paid.
How to Stop Fake Injury Claims
1. Police reports and their absence
Call the police if you’re in an auto accident. Often, the police won’t come to an accident scene unless someone is injured, the wreckage is blocking traffic, or the scene poses a danger to others. If you and the other driver and passengers suffered only property damage, the police may not respond.
Make a note of what happens at the scene. The absence of complaints of injury after the accident can help disprove a fraudulent injury claim, although it is possible for the symptoms of whiplash and other soft tissue injuries to appear days later.
2. Claimant’s statements
When a claimant blurts out something at the scene, especially when it’s related to his actions or physical condition, the circumstances of that statement are normally admissible in court as evidence of the truth. These are known as “Res gestae” statements, and “Admissions against interest.”
“Res gestae” statements
If, at the accident scene, the claimant said, “I’m alright,” or “I’m not hurt,” or words to that effect, those statements are considered res gestae (exceptions to the hearsay rule).
These statements are strong evidence, because the claimant made them at the time of the collision. The courts’ reasoning is, when a traumatic event occurs, most people don’t have time to come up with falsehoods. If they say anything right after an injury event, it’s usually the truth.
Admissions against interest
If, at the time of the collision, the driver of the other car said something like, “I’m sorry. I was going too fast,” or “I didn’t see you,” or any number of similar admissions of fault, those statements are considered admissions against his interest. They’re credible statements showing his state of mind close to the time of the collision.
Lawyers often use statements like these in court to prove or disprove claims for compensation based on fault.
3. Witness statements
After speaking with the other driver and his passengers, look for witnesses to the accident. Find as many as you can, and make sure you get their statements and contact information.
Witness statements can be invaluable, especially when they’re given by people totally unconnected to the accident (e.g. passersby, store owners, other drivers, etc.). These people have nothing to gain from giving their testimony.
For example, a passerby may have noticed, immediately after the accident, the other driver was walking without difficulty. Later, if the driver claims his leg was hurt in the collision, the witness’s statement will help prove the driver is greatly exaggerating, or even faking his leg injury.
Photographs are strong evidence. Showing the cars as they looked immediately after the collision and at the point of impact can go a long way in disproving claims of serious injury.
Use a digital camera or your cell phone to photograph the accident scene, the driver, and his passengers. Photographs and videos of the driver and passengers laughing, or speaking on their cell phones, can be dramatic proof they’re exaggerating or faking their injuries.
5. Your Insurance Company
As soon as possible after the accident, notify your insurance company. You have a responsibility to do so, regardless of fault. Tell the insurance representative you had an accident. Also tell her you’re quite sure the other driver and his passengers were not injured, or at least, not seriously.
Tell her why you believe no one was injured, and offer to provide any evidence you have supporting your position. Insurance companies despise fraudulent claims. They will welcome credible evidence from customers and independent sources.
Other Claim Types
This all applies to other types of personal injury claims, including slip and falls, work injuries, and dog attacks. Whether you’re a homeowner, business owner, or landlord, you can protect yourself from fraudulent injury claims. The more evidence you can provide your insurance company, the better the chance they’ll deny the claim.
There’s only so much you can do to protect yourself. Once a person files what you believe is a fraudulent claim, it’s up to your insurance company to decide whether to pay the claim or deny it. You can’t legally force your insurance company to deny a claim.
Your insurance company may welcome your evidence or reject it. Despite your best efforts, the company may decide to go ahead and settle. The claims adjuster may not think there’s enough evidence of fraud, or believe it’s cheaper for them to pay the claim. Unfortunately, the result for you can be higher premiums or, in some cases, a canceled policy.
Auto Accident Lawsuit Between Two Insurance Carriers
In this case study, an insurance company is trying to recover payment they made for their insured’s damages from the at-fault driver’s insurance company (also known as subrogation).
Lawyer Fails to Present Sufficient Medical Evidence
In this court case, the plaintiff’s personal injury lawyer is seeking damages after a car accident, but he can’t prove the plaintiff meets the serious injury threshold. The defendant files to have the case dismissed for lack of evidence.
How Much is Your Injury Claim Worth?
Find out now with a FREE case review from an attorney…
Visitor Questions on Preventing Fake Injury Claims
What if we believe the claim against us is a scam? My daughter was driving with her roommate minutes from her college around 9:30pm September 2014 getting fast food. She put her blinker on and was merging into the right lane when she side-swiped the car coming up on her right. My daughter was driving a 2016 Dodge Charger and man was driving an older Mercedes.... Read More >>
Can an employee claim an injury if they have no proof of the accident? An employee claimed she fell from 4 stairs down at a client’s house while she was cleaning her home. No one saw the accident. She never sent us photos of the accident. When we asked her at that moment if she was ok and could keep working, she never replied to notify us. Two days... Read More >>
Is my insurance company investigating the accident as they should? My brakes failed in August of this year and I hit another driver who was waiting for a red light. I was going 40mph and I hit the other driver’s rear fender. The driver was up and walking around and told me he was fine several times after the accident, then decided to file a... Read More >>
Minor damage in accident, now other driver claiming bodily injury? I was towing an 18 foot trailer when a car tried to pass me in traffic at about 10 mph. The driver clipped my trailer with the right rear part of her car. She spent the next hour running around yelling on the side of the road as a state trooper, who she stepped into... Read More >>
Can we be sued for a small scratch? One of our tenants told us that a board on her porch was bad. She claims she was walking across the porch when it broke. These boards are about 1 1/2 inches thick. There is no way she was walking across the board when it broke, as these boards are more narrow than a human... Read More >>
Fraudulent injury insurance claim against me? In April 2015 I was in a minor fender bender in a grocery store parking lot. I am the one that hit the guy after he started to make an illegal maneuver and changed his mind. He then hit the breaks and I wasn’t fast enough to hit mine. I did not know until I... Read More >>
How do I pay for property damage but NOT the fake injury? I was parked in an apartment complex. At night I got in my car and my next door neighbor parked behind me with no lights on prior to parking (or after). The street was not lit well. I backed out at 1-2mph and hit the driver’s side right door. She got out screaming immediately. Then... Read More >>
Injuries from minor fender bender? My fiance was driving my car from the gas station. He noticed someone in the turn lane with their blinker on. They continued to sit there while no traffic passed, so he pulled out thinking that he was in the way. As soon as he pulled out, the guy decided to merge onto the road... Read More >>
What recourse do I have against someone who files a false claim? I got a call from my insurance company stating that someone filed a claim against me for a hit and run with injury. This never happened, there is no police report, nothing. I never hit anyone and there is zero damage to my car. However, this person had a very detailed physical description of me... Read More >>
Getting sued for a million dollars after a minor car accident? In 2014 my daughter was 18 years old and she was in an auto accident. She hit another car’s left side bumper (driver’s side). It was a minor accident. There was a police report which stated there was no injury. Our insurance settled everything and the car got fixed. Now, in 2016, one month before... Read More >>
No reported injuries after crash, then four months later they file claim? I was driving with my mother, coming back from college. I was just about to do a turn where there was no stop sign. I looked both ways, making sure nobody was coming from either way. I saw another car but he was clearly over 100 meters away, just making a turn to the street.... Read More >>
Very minor car damage with claim of major personal injury? We had almost come to a complete stop at an intersection when the light turned green. The other driver proceeded through the intersection but stopped suddenly in the middle, for no apparent reason. I tapped him in the center rear end at under 5 mph. We both drove about 3 blocks to find a safe... Read More >>
Driver claiming fake damages after minor car accident… I was in a minor accident which happened after the light changed. The other driver started moving his car and suddenly he stopped and I hit him. Nothing happened to his car and mine got some damage in the grill, which my insurance fixed. He now is claiming some medical visits. The policeman who arrived... Read More >>
Lawsuit for low speed rear end? I was behind a lady exiting a parking lot at a red light. The light turned green and she started to go and I let off the break. She then stopped the car so that someone on the street could get in. I then rolled into the back of her car. I had only let... Read More >>
Injuries 6 months after accident? I was involved in a car wreck six months ago. They charged me with possession of alcohol because I admitted to the cop that I had been drinking, but no alcohol was found and I passed all of my tests. I was not drinking, but was in a state of shock and confusion when being... Read More >>
Set-up by scammer who stopped short after green light… I was out alone running errands here in San Francisco during the early evening, it was a still light out. Myself (female) and the “scammer” (male) were at a red light in the far right lane, me behind the scammer with no other cars around. The light turned green and “scammer” proceeded, then I do... Read More >>
Getting sued for $350,000 after minor fender bender in a parking lot? I was backing out from parking spot at Walmart when the corner of my bumper made contact with another car passing behind me. It scraped from the front door down the side to the passenger door. The other party and I examined the damage and she then pulled into the parking spot next to me.... Read More >>
Filing claim when police report stated no damage or injuries? Eighteen months ago on a rainy day I was involved in a minor accident. Myself and the woman in front were stopped at a red light and when the light changed we both proceeded forward. After around 12 feet the woman just stopped in the middle of the intersection for no reason. At minimal speed,... Read More >>
Defending a false dog bite claim… My two dogs, who are CGC certified (Canine Good Citizen) and registered therapy dogs, ran out to a man in the street walking his dog. My dogs are a golden retriever and Siberian husky, and he was walking a yorkie. The man immediately started yelling at me as to what I was thinking and said... Read More >>
How can I prove a whiplash case? I was involved in an auto accident on 22 Jan 2015. I was following a police car in a 25mph zone. He turned right, then suddenly executed a very fast U turn directly in my path. It should be noted that he turned on his emergency lights almost at the completion of his u turn,... Read More >>
Getting sued for over $100,000 for a minor rear end accident? Last year I was involved in a ‘fender bender’ accident. The guy I hit was driving a big Chevy express van, and I was driving a midsize pickup truck. He stopped at a yellow light before it turned red and I was going 5mph above the limit and rear ended him. The impact was felt... Read More >>
Exaggerated, inflated claim after a minor car accident? I was involved in a minor car accident and now I’m getting sued for over $35,000. I know that this is absolutely ridiculous, exaggerated and inflated. Nobody was injured and we both drove away in our own cars after the accident. How can this person sue me for so much money? Aren’t there laws against... Read More >>
Driver claiming injury after minor rear end collision? I got into an accident on the highway one day. There was a highway entrance ahead, so the entrance lane merged with the right lane. Due to two lanes merging into one, many cars on the right were slowing down. I kept a good distance from the car in front of me, but the car... Read More >>
Woman Says She Tripped on Our Sidewalk… A lady showed up at our door and said she tripped on our sidewalk 2 weeks ago…she said she can’t remember the day it happened. She told us she needs dental work due to the injury which will cost $3,500. She has no witnesses, there was no visible damage to her face, and no visible... Read More >>
Dog Park Accident… I saw a lady at the dog park scream and yell that a bunch of dogs had ran passed her and injured her knee. Her husband ran in, from outside of the gate and said, “oh, she has a bad knee already”. They sat there for a while and then he carried her out. A... Read More >>
Frivolous Car Accident Lawsuit… My Wife was at a gas station on a corner. The light on the corner was red with a couple of cars stopped at the light. She pulled out at about 3-5 mph. In an attempt to pull into the left hand turn lane, she continued out and was struck by a full size van... Read More >>